The unexpected implications of AI: Insights, risks, and success strategies 

Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming industries, including the accounting profession. Once considered a futuristic concept, AI tools are now integral to many daily workflows — from automating routine processes to analyzing complex data sets.

The potential benefits of AI — efficiency, improved accuracy, etc. — are undeniable, but they also have unexpected implications. AI challenges traditional notions of trust, leadership, and professional judgment and amplifies concerns over data privacy, ethical use, and bias in decision-making.

This report examines the complexities of AI’s role in accounting firms — including its impact on efficiency, trust, and leadership — while also discussing relevant AI-powered software solutions that are shaping the future of the profession. By exploring the promise and potential pitfalls, firm leaders can navigate the evolving AI landscape responsibly and effectively.

Understanding AI today

Artificial intelligence falls into two broad types — strong AI and weak AI. The difference lies in the levels of capability:

• Strong AI, also known as general AI, is the concept of machines that possess human-like cognitive abilities. In theory, strong AI can think, reason, and make decisions independently, with a level of understanding comparable to that of humans. While this form of AI remains a vision for the future, we see it often in science fiction. Developing strong AI would require machines to possess consciousness and awareness, which remains far from reality.
• Weak AI, on the other hand, refers to AI systems designed for specific tasks or narrow domains. Often called “narrow AI,” these systems excel at solving specific problems but lack the generalization abilities of human cognition. Narrow AI might simulate intelligent behavior but does not possess true understanding or awareness. Current AI applications are narrow AI, focusing on tasks like image recognition, natural-language processing (NLP), or data analysis. They are highly effective within their designated domains but cannot adapt to tasks outside their scope.

The accounting profession is already applying narrow AI in various areas. For example, a firm might have software that automates tax document categorization or AI-driven predictive analytics to help forecast financial trends. However, despite its capabilities in these specific applications, narrow AI remains limited to predefined functions; it cannot adapt to new tasks outside its programming.

SurePrep: Harnessing the power of AI for tax preparation

SurePrep streamlines processes by automating the assembly of tax returns; electronically delivering tax returns, vouchers, and invoices; and enabling e-signatures so accounting professionals can focus on higher-value activities.

SurePrep is dedicated to bringing innovation to 1040 tax processes. Along with 1040SCAN, our industry-leading tax preparation automation software, SPbinder, the most productive tax work paper software available, and TaxCaddy, the ultimate 1040 tax collaboration platform, SurePrep’s AI capabilities help firms deliver faster, more accurate results while empowering professionals to focus on strategic insights and client relationships.

Generative AI and its capabilities

Generative AI (GenAI) is a subset of AI that goes beyond simply analyzing or predicting data — it creates new content or data based on existing patterns. Unlike traditional AI models focusing on tasks like classification or forecasting, GenAI produces new outputs, such as text, images, or even music.

One of the most well-known applications of generative AI is ChatGPT, a large-language model that generates human-like text responses based on the prompts it receives. Accountants can use it to draft emails and blog posts and answer complex questions. Its ability to understand context, respond to follow-up questions, and provide detailed explanations makes it a powerful tool whenever clear communication and quick access to information are needed.

Microsoft Copilot is embedded within Microsoft Office tools like Word, Excel, and Outlook and leverages GenAI to help users create content, analyze data, and streamline workflows. For example, it can automatically draft reports based on raw data or summarize lengthy documents, reducing the time spent on repetitive tasks.

AI opportunities and benefits

One transformative aspect of AI in accounting is its ability to enhance efficiency. By automating routine and time-consuming tasks, AI allows firms to focus on higher-value activities that require human expertise and judgment.

Other benefits of AI include:

• Automation of routine tasks. AI-powered tools streamline repetitive workflows like document categorization, invoice processing, and tax preparation. Similarly, tools that leverage NLP extract essential information from contracts and other financial documents, saving hours of tedious work.
• Time savings and productivity improvements. Automation enabled by AI translates into measurable time savings. Tasks that once took hours or days can now be completed in minutes. For example, AI tools embedded in accounting software can reconcile accounts, identify discrepancies, and even flag potential compliance issues in real time.
• Predictive analysis and data insights. AI excels at analyzing large datasets to identify patterns, trends, and anomalies that might not be immediately apparent to human analysts. For example, AI tools can forecast cash flow, model tax scenarios, and assess financial risks with a very high level of precision. Predictive analytics tools can help firms anticipate client needs, optimize financial strategies, and make proactive decisions.

CoCounsel Tax: An invaluable asset for tax professionals

CoCounsel Tax is a revolutionary tax research platform designed to simplify complex tax laws and regulations. By integrating AI-powered features, CoCounsel Tax helps users quickly find relevant answers, access authoritative sources, and stay ahead of tax law changes. Its intuitive interface and advanced search capabilities make it an essential tool for tax professionals seeking efficiency and accuracy in their research workflows.

Augmentation, not replacement

While fears about AI replacing human jobs are natural, the reality is that AI is far more effective as a tool for augmentation than as a replacement for human expertise. AI enhances the role of professionals by taking on repetitive tasks, allowing them to focus on activities that require critical thinking and creativity.

AI also complements human judgment by offering insights and recommendations that humans can evaluate and act upon. For example, while AI can analyze financial data to flag potential fraud, it is still up to humans to assess the context and determine the appropriate course of action.

AI also creates new opportunities for professionals to develop specialized skills and take on innovative roles. For example, robot trainers ensure AI systems function as intended by fine-tuning algorithms and addressing errors. Data detectives analyze complex datasets to uncover hidden insights and ensure AI models use accurate and unbiased information.

By embracing these opportunities, firms can improve their operations and position themselves to deliver greater value to their clients.

The unexpected implications

AI adoption comes with significant — often unexpected — implications. Thoughtfully addressing these issues is critical to leveraging AI responsibly and effectively.

Bias and ethical concerns

One of the most pressing challenges in AI adoption is its potential to perpetuate and even amplify human biases. AI systems learn from the data they are trained on, and if that data contains inherent biases, the resulting algorithms can replicate or exacerbate those issues.

There are several types of bias in AI:

• Stereotype bias occurs when AI unintentionally reinforces social stereotypes. For example, an AI system trained on biased hiring data may favor certain demographics over others, perpetuating inequality.
• Sampling bias results from training an AI model on an unrepresentative dataset, leading to skewed or unreliable outputs.
• Measuring bias arises when the metrics or benchmarks used to evaluate AI models are biased or flawed.

Data privacy and security

AI relies on large datasets, which introduces data privacy and security risks.

When sensitive financial or personal data is input into AI models, particularly those hosted in the cloud, there is always a risk of that information being exposed or misused. Without adequate safeguards, this data could inadvertently become accessible to unauthorized parties, leading to breaches of confidentiality and trust.

Navigating AI risks

As AI becomes increasingly integral to accounting, we must navigate its risks responsibly. Explainable AI (XAI) and establishing clear AI guidelines help ensure firms can harness AI’s potential while maintaining trust, transparency, and ethical standards.

Explainable AI

AI’s decision-making processes often function as a “black box,” where inputs generate outputs without clear insight into the underlying mechanisms. This lack of transparency undermines trust, particularly in accounting, where accuracy and accountability are foundational.

XAI addresses this challenge by making AI decision-making processes more transparent and interpretable. It provides insights into how AI systems arrive at conclusions so professionals can understand, validate, and trust these decisions.

For example, an XAI-enabled tax compliance system might explain why it flagged a specific deduction or highlighted certain financial trends. Or, if an AI model predicts a risk of audit for a client, XAI can clarify the factors that contributed to that assessment, such as discrepancies in transaction patterns.

Establishing AI guidelines

Adopting AI responsibly requires policies and guidelines that govern its use. These frameworks ensure the firm implements AI ethically, securely, and effectively.

Recommendations to incorporate into your firm’s AI policy include:

• Define acceptable use cases. Establish clear boundaries for how team members can apply AI within the firm. Focus on areas where it can deliver the most value while minimizing risks.
• Address data security and privacy. Ensure AI systems comply with data protection regulations and maintain confidentiality for client information. Policies should outline protocols for handling sensitive data and specify which AI models are acceptable for use.
• Implement monitoring and auditing processes. Regularly review AI systems for accuracy, fairness, and compliance. Monitoring should include audits of training datasets to identify and minimize potential biases.
• Educate your staff. Train employees on AI’s capabilities, limitations, and ethical considerations. An informed workforce is better equipped to use AI responsibly and recognize its potential risks.

 Generative AI can simplify developing your policies. For example, you can use AI tools to draft initial versions of AI guidelines by prompting them with relevant topics, such as data privacy, bias mitigation, or use case restrictions. These drafts require human review and customization to align with the firm’s unique needs. Still, generative AI can provide a solid starting point, reducing the time and effort needed to create comprehensive policies.

Embrace AI thoughtfully

AI holds immense promise for accountants, offering opportunities to enhance efficiency, improve decision-making, and unlock new levels of productivity. Yet, alongside these benefits come risks, including ethical challenges, data privacy concerns, and the potential for overreliance on technology.

To realize AI’s potential while mitigating risks, adopt it responsibly and align its use with human-centric values. Technology alone cannot replace critical thinking, trust, and leadership. By focusing on these uniquely human skills, AI augments humans instead of disrupting them.

The path forward begins with manageable steps, such as:

1. Start small. Implement AI in targeted areas where it can deliver clear value, such as automating routine tasks or enhancing decision-making processes.
2. Educate teams. Train your staff to help them understand AI’s capabilities and limitations.
3. Develop clear policies. Establish guidelines to ensure ethical, secure, and effective AI use, addressing bias, data protection, and accountability concerns.

Firms that embrace AI thoughtfully — balancing innovation with responsibility — will best position themselves to lead in a rapidly changing landscape. By combining the power of technology with the strength of human expertise, your firm can adapt to the future and help shape it. Now is the time to intentionally and carefully take the first step toward integrating AI into your practice.

While adopting AI is essential, equipping your team with the right AI-powered tools will be paramount for success. Powered by trusted content, exclusive editorial enhancements, and innovative technology, CoCounsel Tax enables you to research faster without sacrificing confidence in your results. It includes AI-Assisted Research, a GenAI capability that provides relevant answers to research questions with links to trusted authoritative sources, so you can make more well-informed decisions and complete the remainder of your research with increased efficiency.

Discover the revolutionary power of AI-Assisted Research. To set up a discussion, contact us directly.