Skip to content
PCAOB

PCAOB investor panel selects best critical, key audit matters of 2025

Soyoung Ho, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 10 minute read

Soyoung Ho, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 10 minute read

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board’s (PCAOB) Investor Advisory Group (IAG) presented three exemplary critical audit matters (CAMs) or key audit matters (KAMs) in 2025 audit reports, as selected by the panel among those nominated by the public.

The following three received the most votes among IAG members:

  • Meta Platforms, Inc. – CAM on consolidation accounting for a variable interest entity (VIE) by Ernst & Young
  • HSBC Holdings plc – KAM on expected credit losses – loans & advances to customers by PricewaterhouseCoopers
  • British American Tobacco plc – KAM on provision arising from litigation in Canada by KPMG

The project, which began in 2024, is spearheaded by IAG member Jeffrey Mahoney, general counsel of the Council of Institutional Investors. This was the third annual call for the most decision-useful CAMs or KAMs. Mahoney presented the results during an IAG meeting in Washington on October 21, 2026.

The goal of this annual evaluation is to encourage auditors to keep improving the quality of information communicated to investors, especially because many CAMs have tended to be boilerplate.

In the inaugural vote in 2024, two of the three best CAMs were issued by Deloitte for its audit of Berkshire Hathaway Inc., and the other was issued by EY for its audit of Moderna, Inc.

Last year, Deloitte got the nod for its CAM on Boeing, PwC for its KAM on Rolls Royce, and KPMG for the KAM on Compass Group.

For this year, the panel voted on 14 nominated matters submitted by nine individuals; seven each were CAMs and KAMs, according to Mahoney. All seven KAMs came from audit reports of U.K. companies that file Form 20-F with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as foreign private issuers.

CAMs are required under PCAOB standards. KAMs were developed by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board.

This is the first time there was a nomination for a CAM or KAM prepared by a non-Big Four firm. Grant Thornton’s CAM on Symbotic Inc. was nominated, although it did not receive one of the top three votes.

Meta CAM by EY

Meta’s CAM was the only audit matter nominated independently by two individuals, including IAG member Gary Walsh, a principal with Luther King Capital Management.

Walsh said the buildout of artificial intelligence has been a big issue for investors.

He looked at the Magnificent Seven AI companies and 13 other companies involved in AI, and Meta’s CAM on VIEs came out on top, calling it “arguably the most decision-useful” for investors “because it addresses a fundamental question about the company’s financial position, which assets, liabilities, and economic obligations should appear on Meta’s balance sheet.”

In particular, Meta holds a 20% membership interest in a data center development venture intended to support its expanding computing infrastructure and AI capabilities.

“The accounting challenge is that the legal ownership percentage alone does not determine whether a company must consolidate or not. Instead, the analysis requires determining whether Meta is the venture’s primary beneficiary under the applicable accounting rules,” Walsh explained. “This makes the CAM especially important. It concerns not simply the valuation of an asset, but the accounting treatment of a large, complex business arrangement.”

EY identified the judgment on which the accounting depends: whether, and which party has, the power to direct the activities that most significantly affect the venture’s economic performance, he said. EY evaluated Meta’s internal controls, read the relevant agreements, assessed management’s determination of the primary beneficiary, and reviewed the related financial statement disclosures.

Meta determined that it did not have the requisite decision-making authority and concluded that it was not the primary beneficiary. Thus, Meta did not consolidate the VIE.

“EY did not report a disagreement with that conclusion but explicitly described auditing it as especially challenging because of the significant judgment involved,” Walsh said. “This specificity distinguishes this CAM from disclosures that merely identify broad areas of uncertainty. It tells investors exactly which accounting judgment deserves scrutiny and what evidence the auditor considered.”

Olga Usvyatsky, an accounting expert who previously worked at Audit Analytics, also nominated the same CAM because “it’s drawing attention to an economically significant and complex transaction. It concerns an accounting decision that depends on facts and judgments that investors cannot easily validate on their own.”

She explained that the challenge for an investor is that this determination is based on the contractual rights and decision-making provisions governed by agreements that are not known publicly.

“The audit firm, on the other hand, has sufficient information needed to evaluate management’s conclusions,” she said. “EY provided a useful description of its audit work, including its review of the agreements and management analysis.”

HSBC KAM by PwC

PwC’s KAM for HSBC was nominated jointly by Karla Zehms of the University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Business and Jessica Nylen of the University of Wisconsin-Whitewater.

Nylen said that they nominated HSBC based on findings from their research.

In 2025, HSBC had a KAM and a CAM on expected credit losses, which were written by the same auditor for the same company in the same year.

But “they differ sharply. And our research shows that this kind of gap carries value-relevant information,” Nylen said.

They only looked at companies that are cross-listed on U.S. and European stock exchanges. And they found that KAMs outnumbered CAMs – 3.1 versus 2.5. Moreover, KAMs were longer, with more expressions of uncertainty and descriptions of audit procedures.

They found that when KAMs cover more than CAMs, investors place lower valuation weights on reported earnings and book values, and companies’ earnings are less persistent.

“So that pattern is consistent with investors treating that incremental content in the key audit matter as a signal about how much to rely on the audited numbers,” she said.

As for HSBC, Nylen said PwC’s KAM was 748 words while its CAM was 394 words.

The KAM had nearly three times the share of uncertainty words. The KAM described 15 distinct audit procedures; the CAM described seven.

“But the numbers don’t tell the whole story. If you read them side by side, the two disclosures tell you very different things about the audit,” she said.

The KAM conveyed information about where PwC focused its attention on: tariff and trade policy volatility, Hong Kong commercial real estate collateral, higher allowances on newly defaulted exposures, whether climate risk had a material effect on the estimate.

“It also tells you what PwC did about it,” she said. “They observed management’s challenge in governance forums. They tested specific controls over model validation and data flows. They brought in economic experts and modeling specialists. They independently reperformed ECL calculations. They had the Hong Kong component team challenge discounted cash flow assumptions, and they tested collateral valuations. And they tell you what PwC concluded, which is that the allowance was reasonable. And they list the three observations PwC reported to the audit committee.”

By contrast, the CAM’s first paragraph defines expected credit losses and describes management’s calculation. But this is already in the company’s footnotes. Its second paragraph explains in generic terms why PwC labeled this as a CAM. Then the procedures paragraph lists categories like test controls, evaluate methodology, evaluate scenarios, test data, use specialists without the specifics that would let an investor judge the depth of the work.

“So, reading the two side by side, we found little in the critical audit matter that was not also in the key audit matter,” she said. “And ultimately, while both disclosures tell an investor that expected credit losses were a hard area of the audit. Only the key audit matter tells them what made it hard, what PwC did about it, and then what PwC concluded.”

British American Tobacco KAM by KPMG

Jared Goodman, senior equity portfolio manager at the Colorado Public Employees Retirement Association, nominated British American Tobacco KAM by KPMG.

Mahoney pointed out that Goodman is the only person to have nominated two IAG-winning audit matters for two years in a row.

Goodman said that the KAMs from last year and this year have a lot in common. “That’s not by coincidence.” They were both reported under the U.K.’s Financial Reporting Council regime, which is “widely known as usually the best of the KAMs.”

For British American Tobacco, he found that KPMG identified an issue with lawsuits, an area about which investors typically are not very knowledgeable.

There is a lot of measurement uncertainty within lawsuits, which are very complex. The lawsuit “could have a huge impact on the financials, which is one of my bigger pet peeves with many of the CAMs, is the sense that you know they select CAMs that are not very material to investors,” he said. “My biggest example would be goodwill. It’s not something investors spend a lot of time on, but it’s something we see a lot of CAMs on.”

Goodman said that KPMG listed the audit steps and provided an evaluation of the audit process. “A lot of investors have that expectation and gap of what’s happening on an audit and don’t have necessarily the knowledge of where you know understanding of how audits get done,” he said. “Just listing these steps and describing them.. is a big step forward.”

Further, KPMG described the history and the complexity of the litigation.

“And then from year to year, they describe the change in the risks of this measurement item, which also is important, where the risk levels have reduced year over year due to repayments on the lawsuit, and then finally they gave you a worst-case scenario, which was massively different,” he said. “It was somewhere around $20 billion with potential maximum litigation risk versus the 2 billion that was being recorded. I found that to be particularly helpful as well.”

PCAOB’s post-implementation review of CAMs

In the meantime, the PCAOB, in its latest update to its agenda, noted that the staff plans to conduct a further PIR of CAMs before determining whether more research, standard-setting, or guidance would be needed.

At the IAG meeting, PCAOB Chairman Demetrios Logothetis said that the comparisons between U.S. CAMs and U.K. KAMs “may be an area where we may want to invest some of our resources and work with the other regulators to come up with some ideas.”

“I mean, this is intriguing, right? And it probably goes back, as George [Botic] was explaining to me, goes back to the standard,” he said. “But maybe we ought to take a look and see how the implementation has gone, and why other places… other regulators may be doing a better job, and vice versa.”

Botic noted that CAMs were previously on the research agenda to understand any underlying root causes of the differences.

“Okay, yeah, let’s try and do that,” Logothetis responded.

 

Take your tax and accounting research to the next level with Checkpoint Edge and CoCounsel. Get instant access to AI-assisted research, expert-approved answers, and cutting-edge tools like Advisory Maps and State Charts. Try it today and transform the way you work! Subscribe now and discover a smarter way to find answers.

More answers

A Tale of Two Above the Line Deductions

By Lynn Bossenbroek, CPA The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (“the 2025 Act”), introduced several important modifications to increase charitable …