Skip to content
Federal Tax

States decouple from tax breaks as foreign income rules create winners, losers, pros say

Tim Shaw, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 6 minute read

Tim Shaw, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 6 minute read

After the midterms, states are likelier to decouple from federal tax breaks than raise income tax rates, while new foreign income rules favor multinationals with U.S. assets over those invested abroad, two tax professionals say.

States favor decoupling over income tax hikes

Greg Rottjakob, principal and national leader of Ryan’s State Income and Franchise Tax practice, told Checkpoint he expects states to take an “elongated period of time” to respond to the One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB), P.L. 119-21, as they did with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), P.L. 115-97.

Democrats flipped at least five governorships, Reuters reported, and Rottjakob said state responses could be “election oriented.” Democratic-leaning states appear more inclined to adopt base-broadening federal changes and reject deductions such as bonus depreciation, he said.

The OBBB made 100% bonus depreciation under IRC § 168(k) permanent and allowed immediate expensing of domestic research or experimental expenditures under new IRC § 174A. Decoupling generally stretches those deductions over a longer period for state purposes, Rottjakob said.

States have been decoupling because, under the OBBB, “the states took on more of the cost the federal government used to front,” he said. Starting in fiscal year 2027, the federal share of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program administrative costs falls to 25% from 50%.

Rottjakob expects new leaders to keep supporting those programs through decoupling or rate increases, and decoupling “is not as negative from a voter perspective.”

Rate increases also wouldn’t have to hit income taxes, Rottjakob noted. “Really, the bigger taxes are sales tax and property tax,” he said. “So all you got to do is change the rate there, and you’re going to collect more than you are on the income tax side.”

Foreign income rules reward U.S. assets

Most OBBB international changes apply to tax years beginning after 2025, and “each taxpayer is going to be in a different situation,” Samuel Tae, principal in Ryan’s International Income Tax Consulting practice, told Checkpoint.

The law renamed global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI), which U.S. shareholders of controlled foreign corporations (CFCs) must include in income annually, as net CFC tested income (NCTI), and set the IRC § 250 deduction for NCTI at 40%, for a 12.6% rate before foreign tax credits.

“There’s definitely winners and losers,” Tae said. Winners are U.S. multinationals with substantial fixed assets at home, because those assets no longer reduce their deduction for foreign-derived deduction eligible income from foreign sales and services. Interest and research costs also are no longer allocated against that income.

“The losers are the ones that used to have a lot of capex outside the U.S.,” he said. The OBBB repealed the exclusion for a deemed 10% return on CFCs’ qualified business asset investment (QBAI), their depreciable tangible property, which Tae said, “used to shelter the GILTI inclusion.”

The law also raised the deemed-paid credit for foreign taxes on NCTI from 80% to 90%, a change Rottjakob flagged and Tae said should help taxpayers operating in higher-tax jurisdictions.

States reach for foreign income

Larger credits matter at the state level, Rottjakob said, because an “ever mounting number of states” try to include the income in their tax base, often with “no factor representation or limited factor representation” and no credit for foreign taxes. Factor representation adds a CFC’s sales, property, and payroll to the apportionment formula, diluting the state’s share.

Some Ryan clients owed no additional federal tax on GILTI because of foreign tax credits but still had large inclusions. Rottjakob argues that states are taxing income that bears little incremental federal tax, and with the higher credits, “NCTI fully helps us from a standpoint of making that argument.”

Without QBAI, NCTI reaches more of a CFC’s income, supporting the case that a state inclusion amounts to “a modified worldwide reporting methodology, even though it might not be allowed under the state code,” he said. Worldwide reporting combines the income of a group’s U.S. and foreign affiliates.

In Texas, aligning the franchise tax with OBBB bonus depreciation was billed as a win, but “what’s kind of hidden” is the inclusion of NCTI, Rottjakob said. With Democrats winning the governorship and state House, a new state government could decouple from provisions where that would raise revenue, he added.

Safe harbor eases Pillar Two pressure

Even with Democrats taking control of Congress January 3, Tae doesn’t expect a push for U.S. adoption of Pillar Two, the 15% global minimum tax developed through the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).

Pillar Two lets other countries collect top-up tax from a multinational whose home country hasn’t adopted the regime, Tae said. “There is a parallel system under Pillar Two that says if your country has a robust tax system already … then these punitive global minimum tax provisions are not going to apply.”

Adopted in January by the OECD’s Inclusive Framework, that side-by-side safe harbor treats such top-up tax as zero for groups based in a qualified country. Only the U.S. is listed, and Tae doesn’t foresee the OECD “pulling the U.S. off that list.”

“I feel like now we’re not as worried about adopting Pillar Two,” he said. The safe harbor doesn’t cover qualified domestic minimum top-up taxes, which countries can levy on low-taxed profits within their borders.

Weighing a Democratic corporate rate increase, Tae noted that the TCJA cut the rate from 35%, arguably higher than most OECD countries at the time, to 21%, probably lower than most today. Since then, the U.S. “has become a favored jurisdiction in terms of tax planning,” he said.

“Now, if we were to increase that rate, would it make a material impact on the amount of investments in the U.S.? I don’t think so,” Tae said.

 

Take your tax and accounting research to the next level with Checkpoint Edge and CoCounsel. Get instant access to AI-assisted research, expert-approved answers, and cutting-edge tools like Advisory Maps and State Charts. Try it today and transform the way you work! Subscribe now and discover a smarter way to find answers.

More answers