Recent appellate rulings have left partners uncertain whether they qualify for the limited partner exception to self-employment tax, while a Chief Counsel memo gives multinationals room to defend cost allocations under audit, KPMG practitioners said during a November 12 webcast.
The TaxWatch session also covered research credit exams and dispute resolution. Mary Slonina, a managing director with the Tax Controversy and Dispute Resolution group of KPMG’s Washington National Tax practice, moderated.
Circuits narrow the exception
Under IRC § 1402(a)(13), net earnings from self-employment, which are subject to Social Security and Medicare tax, exclude a limited partner’s distributive share, other than guaranteed payments.
In 2023, the Tax Court held in Soroban Capital Partners LP, 161 T.C. 310, that a functional test applies to state-law limited partners, said Ali DeSantis, a managing director at KPMG. Taxpayers in that case and two similar cases, Denham and Sirius, appealed.
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled first, rejecting the functional analysis in Sirius. In August, it replaced that opinion on rehearing with one captioned K Alain LLLP v. Commissioner, 184 F.4th 766, holding that partners who play a significant role in managing or running the business are not limited partners.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals followed in September, affirming the Tax Court in Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner, No. 25-2079, and holding that a limited partner must have limited liability and not run, manage, or control the partnership’s business.
According to DeSantis, the 2nd Circuit’s test treats any control or management activity as disqualifying, while the 5th Circuit’s disqualifies only a significant role. Neither draws a bright line, she said, and the 2nd Circuit saw little daylight between them. The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has yet to rule in Denham.
“It leaves us with a lot of uncertainty,” she said. The analysis is particularly hard for partners outside senior management, she added, and “we’re really going to need more cases to better understand how this functional test is going to apply.”
KPMG’s position is that taxpayers who keep claiming the exception need to satisfy the reasonable basis standard and disclose it with the return, DeSantis said.
Transfer pricing sees flexibility, scrutiny
Lillie Sullivan, a managing director in KPMG’s Washington National Tax practice, called a May 2026 Chief Counsel memorandum on intercompany service cost allocations “generally pretty taxpayer favorable,” saying it helps taxpayers defend their methods in exams.
The memo makes clear that multiple approaches, not only the single best method, can satisfy the arm’s-length standard, she said. It also acknowledges that alignment with internal management reporting can support a method’s reasonableness and that moving to a more reliable approach does not necessarily mean the original method was not at arm’s length.
There is “a little bit more flexibility in the system here than you might have thought, or that some exam teams may have been asserting,” Sullivan said. Still, the memo should not be read as “a blanket approval to change allocation methods,” she cautioned, noting its facts involved a move to a more refined and accurate method.
Financial transactions also face scrutiny, Sullivan said, particularly implicit support, the benefit a group member gets from belonging to a multinational group even without a formal guarantee. Some jurisdictions insist that affiliation improves a borrower’s credit rating and lowers the arm’s-length interest rate, while others prefer a standalone rating, she said.
Research credit audits, resolution options
Research credit examinations remain “a hot button issue for the IRS,” said Aaron Vaughan, a principal at KPMG. He said the credit is often scoped into exams of refund claims for years in which it was claimed, even when another item triggered the refund.
“[I]f I can stress one thing above all else, it’s documentation in a format that the IRS is going to accept or find processable because they are going to need that help,” Vaughan said. Job titles have become “a pretty easy and I dare say lazy reach for a lot of IRS engineers and state examiners,” who may assume a vice president is not directly contributing to research, he said.
In George, T.C. Memo. 2026-10, the Tax Court weighed each project’s evidence separately, Vaughan said. Two projects looked very similar, but “the evidentiary pictures are different, and they therefore deserve different treatment,” he said.
Staffing cuts at the IRS, including the departure of 33% of revenue agents in a year, affect the pace of examinations, Slonina said.
She urged taxpayers to consider pre-filing and post-filing alternative dispute resolution options, which can bring certainty sooner. Slonina reported an uptick in Fast Track Settlement use before cases move to formal appeals.
Chris Whitcomb, also a managing director in KPMG’s Washington National Tax practice, said exam teams are encouraging the program at the close of an exam, though not every case suits it. “[S]ometimes it’s advantageous to get things out of that exam posture,” he said.
Take your tax and accounting research to the next level with Checkpoint Edge and CoCounsel. Get instant access to AI-assisted research, expert-approved answers, and cutting-edge tools like Advisory Maps and State Charts. Try it today and transform the way you work! Subscribe now and discover a smarter way to find answers.