Skip to content
Federal Tax

Outbound planning starts with modeling, tax pros advise

Tim Shaw, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 5 minute read

Tim Shaw, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 5 minute read

Tax advisers structuring U.S. operations abroad should model each option and navigate anti-deferral and outbound transfer rules, some reshaped by recent legislation, panelists said November 16 at New York University’s 85th Institute on Federal Taxation.

The panel featured Andersen managing directors Joe Calianno, the firm’s U.S. National Tax leader for international tax, and Sean Dokko, of its New York office. William Sherman, a partner at Holland & Knight LLP and the institute’s international tax chair, moderated.

Modeling drives entity choice

Choosing between a foreign corporation and a flow-through structure, such as a foreign branch or disregarded entity, turns on projected income or losses and what they mean for the U.S. owner, Calianno said. Owners may gravitate toward certain defaults, he said, but “it really is a modeling exercise, and I can’t emphasize that more.”

In the corporate context, a corporation is typically the default, but that “doesn’t necessarily mean that’s the most efficient,” Dokko said. Converting a corporation into a flow-through is much easier than the reverse, he said, a gap Calianno attributed largely to the outbound transfer rules.

Dokko said: “a large portion of tax planning … is derived through check-the-box planning.” Calianno said taxpayers who never filed a needed classification election can sometimes obtain retroactive relief under Rev Proc 2009-41.

For individuals, Sherman said, the model compares a flow-through vehicle with a controlled foreign corporation (CFC) structure, “perhaps making the 962 election, computing my personal tax at the corporate rate, but then when distributions of cash flow actually come out, then you have this additional tax burden.”

Downward attribution limit returns

The One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB), P.L. 119-21, reinstated IRC § 958(b)(4), which bars treating a U.S. person as owning stock owned by a foreign person for purposes of the CFC rules. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), P.L. 115-97, had repealed it.

In the rush to enact the TCJA, Dokko said, lawmakers “simply just pulled 958(b)(4) out of the code,” and many foreign corporations became CFCs. For one U.S. corporate client, he and Calianno prepared about 1,600 returns on Form 5471, Information Return of U.S. Persons With Respect to Certain Foreign Corporations, Dokko said, calling it “a compliance nightmare.”

The restored rule applies to tax years of foreign corporations beginning after December 31, 2025. The OBBB also added IRC § 951B, which Dokko said targets the inverted structure that originally concerned Congress. Under it, a U.S. person that would own more than 50% of a non-CFC foreign corporation if downward attribution applied picks up its pro rata share of that corporation’s subpart F income and net CFC tested income.

Calianno said the IRS and Treasury need to issue guidance on how § 951B interacts with other regimes, including the passive foreign investment company (PFIC) rules.

Cash can trigger PFIC status

Even a U.S. corporation that avoids CFC status must watch the PFIC rules, Dokko said, because PFIC dividends do not qualify for the IRC § 245A dividends received deduction. A foreign corporation is a PFIC if at least 75% of its gross income is passive or at least 50% of its assets are passive.

Companies typically trip the asset test because of how the IRS has historically viewed cash, Dokko said, pointing to a decades-old notice treating it as passive. A proposed working capital exception is “very limited,” he said. Calianno called cash “the one asset I think more often than not creates an issue,” especially for companies receiving a large infusion of capital.

Sherman said the issue often hits service businesses with few tangible assets, because a receivable is a good asset but becomes a bad one if collected as cash on the last day of a quarter. “It’s bizarre telling people don’t collect your receivables at the end of a quarter,” he said.

Dokko called the default excess distribution regime “very punitive,” with an interest charge that can exceed the tax itself. The qualified electing fund regime, which can preserve capital gains rates on a sale, is “probably the least worst option of the three,” he said.

Outbound transfers carry a tax cost

Putting cash into a foreign corporation is usually not a big deal, Calianno said, but transferring appreciated property or intellectual property (IP) brings IRC § 367 into play. Section 367(a) generally requires gain recognition, asset by asset, and the TCJA repealed an active trade or business exception.

A U.S. transferor of foreign stock that will be a 5% shareholder generally can avoid gain by entering into a five-year gain recognition agreement, Calianno said. Dokko noted it also requires extending the statute of limitations.

For IP, § 367(d) treats an outbound transfer as a sale in exchange for deemed annual payments, generally a foreign-source royalty over the property’s useful life. Calianno said the definition of IP is broad, and Dokko pointed to workforce and goodwill as major examples.

Converting a branch or disregarded entity into a foreign corporation can also trigger branch loss, dual consolidated loss, and overall foreign loss recapture, Calianno said, all of which “could add a pretty large tax cost” to the move.

 

Take your tax and accounting research to the next level with Checkpoint Edge and CoCounsel. Get instant access to AI-assisted research, expert-approved answers, and cutting-edge tools like Advisory Maps and State Charts. Try it today and transform the way you work! Subscribe now and discover a smarter way to find answers.

More answers

Taxpayer Receipt of Staking Rewards

Background On 6/4/26, the U.S. Tax Court held that cryptocurrency staking rewards received by a taxpayer were includible in gross …