A group of tax experts, including two former IRS commissioners and a former National Taxpayer Advocate, has urged the Treasury Department and the IRS to remove a proposed citizenship question from individual income tax returns for tax year 2026.
Former IRS Commissioners John A. Koskinen and Danny Werfel signed the joint comment letter October 26. Werfel is now a senior fellow at Johns Hopkins University School of Government and Policy. Nina Olson, executive director of the Center for Taxpayer Rights and former National Taxpayer Advocate, also signed, as did the Tax Law Center at NYU Law and the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
Treasury and the IRS sought public comment on the draft Form 1040 and other forms for tax year 2026. The draft form asks, “At the time you file your return, are you, and your spouse if filing jointly, a U.S. citizen, U.S. national, or an alien lawfully authorized to work in the U.S.?”
Voluntary compliance
The signers wrote that the tax system depends heavily on voluntary compliance and that the IRS has never before proposed asking all individual filers about their citizenship status. Doing so “is likely to produce a chilling effect,” the letter stated.
The letter said that risk is heightened by the IRS’ sharing of taxpayer data with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) under an April 2025 agreement between Treasury and the Department of Homeland Security. The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia and the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts each preliminarily enjoined the agreement, finding that the IRS violated IRC § 6103 by sharing address information of about 47,000 tax filers with ICE. The District of Columbia U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals later affirmed one of the D.C. district court’s rulings.
The letter also cited the Budget Lab at Yale, which estimated that reduced tax compliance under the agreement could lower federal revenues by roughly $300 billion over a decade, with a range of $150 billion to just under $500 billion.
Existing procedures
According to the letter, the question asks about U.S. work authorization, not citizenship, and work authorization is irrelevant for most tax purposes. All U.S. residents, as defined in IRC § 7701(b), are taxed on their worldwide income regardless of citizenship or immigration status, the signers noted.
Taxpayers generally must already claim the few benefits that require a work-authorized Social Security number, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit and the Child Tax Credit, on forms and schedules that explain the eligibility rules, the letter said. By attesting under penalty of perjury that they meet those rules, taxpayers are “already effectively answering ‘yes’ to a more precise and tailored version of the proposed citizenship question where relevant,” the signers wrote.
The letter added that the IRS checks taxpayer identification numbers against Social Security Administration records and an internal database, the Data Master-1, and uses that information to deny ineligible claims. Filers with an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) are also already identifiable, the signers wrote, because ITINs, issued only to people who cannot obtain a Social Security number, always begin with the number 9.
Disputing Treasury, IRS rationale
Treasury and the IRS have said in press statements that the question is meant to strengthen tax administration, protect refundable credits from abuse, and help ensure those credits go only to taxpayers who are legally eligible under federal law. The signers argued that this explanation “does not make sense” and that, under the Administrative Procedure Act, the agencies must consider the question’s potential chilling effect and revenue loss.
The letter also said the question would not help administer separate proposed rules (REG-119882-25) applying the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996, P.L. 104-193, to the refunded portion of certain refundable tax credits. Those rules would use a proposed Schedule 3-A that asks whether a claimant is a “qualified alien,” a category the Form 1040 question does not address.
Asking similar but distinct immigration-related questions on both forms is likely to cause confusion, increase mistakes, and discourage eligible filers from claiming credits, the signers wrote.
‘Sharp’ policy change
The group called the question “a sharp reversal of Treasury and IRS policy.” When the IRS proposed the ITIN in 1995, it said the numbers were “intended for tax use only” and would create “no inference regarding the immigration status of a foreign person,” the signers noted.
They also quoted former IRS Commissioner Mark Everson, who told Congress that “our tax laws make no distinction” between immigrants who are legally employed and those who are not.
“Adding the proposed citizenship question to the Form 1040 would be arbitrary and capricious, and the proposed citizenship question should be removed from the Form 1040 before it is finalized for the 2026 tax year,” the letter stated.
Take your tax and accounting research to the next level with Checkpoint Edge and CoCounsel. Get instant access to AI-assisted research, expert-approved answers, and cutting-edge tools like Advisory Maps and State Charts. Try it today and transform the way you work! Subscribe now and discover a smarter way to find answers.