Skip to content
Federal Tax

Prediction market contracts lack clear tax treatment, attorneys say

Tim Shaw, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 5 minute read

Tim Shaw, Checkpoint News  Senior Editor

· 5 minute read

Prediction market event contracts could be taxed as wagers, as derivatives with capital gain treatment, or as ordinary income with nondeductible losses, and no guidance settles which applies, two tax attorneys said November 17 at New York University’s 85th Institute on Federal Taxation.

Trading volume on Kalshi and Polymarket, the two largest U.S. prediction markets, is estimated at around $53 billion, activity “with respect to which there is no tax guidance,” said Vadim Novik, a tax partner at Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson LLP. Novik said the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regulates both as designated contract markets offering swaps, a status that “may affect the federal income tax analysis.”

Wagering and the 90% loss limit

If a Knicks game contract on Kalshi pays out the same as a bet on DraftKings, “it’s really hard to say that those contracts should be taxed differently,” said Nicholas Seaman, an associate in Fried Frank’s tax department. Sports contracts made up 87% of Kalshi’s volume last year and 38% of Polymarket’s, he said.

Wagering proceeds are ordinary income, Seaman said. Under IRC § 165(d), as amended by the One Big Beautiful Bill, P.L. 119-21, the deduction for wagering losses is limited to 90% of those losses, and only to the extent of wagering gains, for tax years beginning after December 31, 2025.

That limit “can be pretty damaging” for market makers and arbitragers earning thin margins, Seaman said. An arbitrager capturing a $2 spread could deduct only $81 of a $90 loss, he said. “Now you have $11 of income, and the tax on that might exceed the actual profit that you earned.”

Novik said states including Nevada and New Jersey have sued Kalshi, claiming it runs an unlicensed gaming business, and the CFTC has intervened to argue federal law preempts state gaming law. Some tax advisors and market participants use that position to argue the contracts are not wagers for federal income tax purposes, he said.

Hurdles to Section 1256 treatment

Treatment under IRC § 1256 is “far and away the best,” Novik said. Section 1256 contracts are marked to market at year-end, with gain or loss treated as 60% long-term and 40% short-term capital gain or loss.

A regulated futures contract requires mark-to-market variation margin, which event contracts lack, Seaman said. “They’re all fully collateralized.” He also questioned who would be the grantor of a nonequity option when an exchange only matches opposing positions.

Whether a contract with binary economics can qualify as an option, a question “on which billions of dollars of income turn,” has no definitive answer, Novik said.

Capital or ordinary at maturity

Selling a contract that is neither a wager nor a § 1256 contract generally produces capital gain or loss, Novik said. Holding it to maturity turns on IRC § 1234A, which treats gain or loss from terminating a right or obligation with respect to a capital asset as capital gain or loss.

Stock-linked contracts are “almost certainly” covered, Novik said, while for sports, politics, and weather contracts, taxpayers must “push the boundaries” of § 1234A. Treating the contract itself as the capital asset “doesn’t square very well with the statutory language,” he said, adding that the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision in Pilgrim’s Pride Corp. v. Commissioner, 779 F.3d 311, cuts against that approach.

Without § 1234A, individuals outside a trading business who hold contracts to maturity could have ordinary income on gains, while losses would likely be miscellaneous itemized deductions, which have been disallowed since 2018, Novik said. By comparison, “I’d rather take the 90% deduction,” he said.

Hedging and cross-border questions

A California property insurer buying earthquake contracts could identify them as hedges under IRC § 1221(a)(7) on the day it enters into them, making gains and losses ordinary, Novik said. Even if the IRS were to treat event contracts as wagers, he said there is a strong argument that hedging treatment should supersede the wagering rules.

For foreign persons trading commodities, IRC § 864(b)(2)(B) provides safe harbors from U.S. net income tax. Because the IRS has historically deferred to the CFTC on what is a commodity, and the CFTC regulates many event contracts as commodities, Novik said the safe harbor position “feels very compelling.”

Sourcing proceeds treated as gambling income subject to withholding is an area where “we sorely need guidance,” Novik said.

 

Take your tax and accounting research to the next level with Checkpoint Edge and CoCounsel. Get instant access to AI-assisted research, expert-approved answers, and cutting-edge tools like Advisory Maps and State Charts. Try it today and transform the way you work! Subscribe now and discover a smarter way to find answers.

More answers