Skip to content
Federal Tax

Court rejects government bid to dismiss scam victim’s refund suit

Checkpoint News Staff  

· 5 minute read

Checkpoint News Staff  

· 5 minute read

A federal district court denied the government’s motion to dismiss a refund suit, holding that a scam victim’s informal letter was a valid refund claim and her formal return was timely filed due to pandemic extensions. (Singh v. United States, 2026 WL 2906665, 9/24/2026)

Romance scam caused $100,000 loss

Juliet R. Singh was the victim of an online dating scam in October 2017, in which a fraudster persuaded her to withdraw $100,000 from her Individual Retirement Account (IRA) and transfer it to him. Singh filed a timely federal income tax return for the 2017 tax year in April 2018. Although the tax code allows deductions for certain losses under IRC § 165, Singh did not claim a theft loss deduction on her return. Instead, she reported the withdrawal as taxable income and paid a resulting tax liability of $28,069.74, which included a 10% early withdrawal penalty.

In July 2019, the IRS’ Holtsville, New York office issued a Notice CP2000 through its Automated Underreported (AUR) system, stating she owed an additional $4,547 on her 2017 return. Singh responded by sending a letter on July 25, 2019, to the IRS’ Kansas City office, explaining that she was scammed out of her savings, had reported the crime to the police, and was seeking hardship relief.

Letter was valid informal refund claim

The district court determined that this letter constituted a valid informal refund claim under the informal claim doctrine, which derives from United States v. Kales (1941). The court noted that a valid informal claim must alert the IRS that a taxpayer seeks a refund and describe the factual basis of the claim.

Singh later perfected her claim by filing Form 1040X, Amended U.S. Individual Tax Return, on October 7, 2022, which the IRS received on October 19, 2022. On the form, she removed the $100,000 withdrawal from her taxable income and requested a refund of $30,601. The court rejected the government’s argument that her attached cover letters could not be considered part of the formal claim because they were not signed under penalties of perjury, explaining that her signature on the Form 1040X covers all attached supporting documents.

Pandemic declarations extend administrative filing deadlines

The government argued that even if the Form 1040X was a valid formal claim, Singh failed to file it within the three-year limitations period defined in IRC § 6511(a). Under normal rules, Singh’s deadline to file an administrative refund claim would have expired in April 2021. However, the court ruled that her filing period was automatically extended under the pre-2021 version of IRC § 7508A(d) due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

In March 2020, President Donald Trump declared a nationwide emergency and a major disaster in New York, where Singh lived. IRC § 7508A(d) provides a mandatory extension of tax-related deadlines in the event of a federally declared disaster. The court calculated that the extension period began on January 20, 2020, and ended 60 days after the latest incident date specified in the disaster declaration. Because a February 2023 administrative notice closed the COVID-19 disaster incident period on May 11, 2023, Singh’s mandatory extension ran until July 10, 2023, making her October 2022 formal claim timely.

The court rejected the government’s contention that extensions under § 7508A(d) are capped at the one-year maximum allowed for discretionary extensions under § 7508A(a). Citing Abdo v. Commissioner (2024) and Kwong v. United States (2025), the court held that mandatory extensions under subsection (d) operate independently of discretionary extensions. Furthermore, the court noted that a November 2021 amendment to § 7508A(d) that limits mandatory extensions was not retroactive and did not apply to disasters declared prior to its enactment.

Statutory lookback period does not bar taxpayer refund

The government also contended that the district court lacked jurisdiction because the lookback period in IRC § 6511(b)(2)(A) barred Singh’s refund. Under § 6511(b)(2)(A), a taxpayer can only recover taxes paid within the three years immediately preceding the filing of the claim. Because Singh paid her 2017 tax liability on June 14, 2018, the government argued that her October 2022 claim fell outside this window.

The court disagreed, holding that § 7508A requires the IRS to exclude the pandemic postponement period from its lookback calculation. By excluding the period of the COVID-19 extension, the court found that Singh’s lookback period ran from June 14, 2018, to January 20, 2020, and then from July 10, 2023, to approximately December 1, 2024. Therefore, the statutory lookback rules did not bar her refund.

For more information about the informal refund claim doctrine, see Checkpoint’s Federal Tax Coordinator 2d ¶ T-6721.

 

Take your tax and accounting research to the next level with Checkpoint Edge and CoCounsel. Get instant access to AI-assisted research, expert-approved answers, and cutting-edge tools like Advisory Maps and State Charts. Try it today and transform the way you work! Subscribe now and discover a smarter way to find answers.

More answers

Trump Accounts for Eligible Children

  By Laura Hanlon, CPA Background A new type of retirement savings vehicle under IRC Sec. 530A, commonly known as …